Modern Leadership: Skills, Styles & How to Lead in the AI Era

Modern leadership is changing. Leaders still need to set direction, make decisions and deliver results, but the environment in which they lead has become more complex.

Teams can be distributed across locations. Technology changes quickly. Employees work across organizational boundaries. Artificial intelligence can assist with analysis, content, decisions and increasingly complex workflows. At the same time, trust, communication, judgment and accountability remain deeply human responsibilities.

This means modern leadership is not simply about having authority or adopting the latest management trend. It is about creating the conditions in which people can understand the direction, contribute effectively, make good decisions and adapt as circumstances change.

This guide explains what modern leadership means, the skills and leadership styles that matter, how to build trust and psychological safety, how to lead hybrid and cross-functional teams, and how leadership is evolving in the AI era.

What Is Modern Leadership?

Modern leadership is the ability to create direction, enable people, make effective decisions and adapt the organization to changing conditions while remaining accountable for outcomes.

It moves beyond a model based primarily on hierarchy and control.

Modern leaders still use authority when necessary, but they also rely on:

  • Influence
  • Trust
  • Communication
  • Collaboration
  • Judgment
  • Coaching
  • Empowerment
  • Adaptability

The goal is not to make leadership less decisive.

It is to make leadership effective in environments where one person cannot possess all the knowledge required to solve every problem.

Why Modern Leadership Matters

Organizations increasingly operate through interconnected teams, digital platforms, partnerships and rapidly changing technologies.

A leader may need to coordinate people from engineering, operations, cybersecurity, finance, product, project management and business functions without directly managing everyone involved.

This changes the nature of leadership.

Success increasingly depends on the ability to align people around a shared purpose rather than simply issue instructions through a hierarchy.

Modern leadership therefore connects:

Direction + People + Decisions + Adaptability + Technology + Accountability

Traditional Leadership vs Modern Leadership

The distinction between traditional and modern leadership should not be exaggerated. Hierarchy, structure and authority remain useful in many organizations.

What has changed is how leaders combine those mechanisms with collaboration, empowerment and distributed expertise.

Traditional Emphasis Modern Leadership Emphasis
Position Influence plus authority
Control Direction and empowerment
Information concentrated at the top Information shared where useful
Instructions Context and outcomes
Individual expertise Collective expertise
Predictability Adaptability
Fixed processes Continuous improvement
Managing people Enabling people to perform
Traditional leadership vs modern leadership comparison showing hierarchy, control, empowerment, influence and long-term growth
Modern leadership shifts the focus from hierarchy and control toward influence, empowerment, context, collaboration and sustainable growth.

This does not mean modern leaders avoid control completely.

In a crisis, regulated environment or high-risk situation, more directive leadership may be appropriate.

Effective leadership is contextual.

Leadership vs Management: What Is the Difference?

Leadership and management are often presented as opposites, but that distinction is too simplistic.

Management typically focuses on organizing resources, coordinating execution, controlling risks and delivering expected outcomes.

Leadership typically emphasizes direction, alignment, motivation, judgment and change.

Strong organizations need both.

A leader who creates an inspiring vision but cannot organize execution may struggle to deliver results.

A manager who executes efficiently without questioning direction may optimize work that no longer creates value.

Many effective professionals therefore need both leadership and management capabilities.

The Modern Leadership Framework

A practical way to understand modern leadership is through six interconnected responsibilities:

Direction → People → Decisions → Adaptability → Technology → Accountability

Modern leadership framework showing direction, people, decisions, adaptability, technology and accountability
Modern leadership combines direction, people, decisions, adaptability, technology and accountability to create stronger teams and better outcomes.

1. Direction

People need to understand where the organization or team is going and why.

Leaders translate strategy into priorities that teams can act on.

2. People

Leaders create conditions where people can contribute their expertise, develop skills and work effectively together.

3. Decisions

Leadership involves making choices when information is incomplete, priorities conflict or trade-offs are unavoidable.

4. Adaptability

Plans need to evolve as technology, markets, customers and organizational conditions change.

5. Technology

Modern leaders do not need to be experts in every technology, but they need enough digital understanding to evaluate opportunities, risks and organizational implications.

6. Accountability

Empowerment does not remove accountability.

Leaders remain responsible for establishing boundaries, monitoring outcomes and addressing problems.

What Makes a Modern Leader Effective?

An effective modern leader turns the leadership framework into daily behavior. That means making direction clear, creating the conditions for people to contribute, making decisions with appropriate speed and evidence, adapting when circumstances change, understanding the role of technology and remaining accountable for outcomes.

The strongest leaders do not rely on a single personality type or leadership style. They combine strategic clarity with trust, judgment, communication and the ability to develop other people.

That leadership experience is closely connected to the wider employee experience and to how organizations attract, develop and retain capability through talent management.

Effective Modern Leadership = Clear Direction + Enabled People + Better Decisions + Adaptability + Digital Awareness + Accountability

Essential Modern Leadership Skills

Modern leadership requires a combination of strategic, interpersonal and decision-making capabilities.

Strategic Thinking

Strategic thinking helps leaders connect today’s actions with longer-term objectives.

It involves asking questions such as:

  • What are we trying to achieve?
  • What is changing around us?
  • Where should we invest?
  • What should we stop doing?
  • What capabilities will we need?
  • What risks are we accepting?

Communication

Leadership communication is not simply about speaking confidently.

Effective leaders need to explain:

  • Direction
  • Priorities
  • Decisions
  • Expectations
  • Trade-offs
  • Change

Good communication reduces ambiguity without pretending that every question already has an answer.

Active Listening

Leaders need information from people closer to customers, systems and operational problems.

Listening helps leaders understand:

  • Risks
  • Ideas
  • Concerns
  • Customer feedback
  • Operational realities
  • Emerging problems

Listening does not mean agreeing with everything.

It means ensuring decisions are informed by relevant perspectives.

Emotional Intelligence

Emotional intelligence can help leaders understand their own reactions and interact more effectively with others.

Useful capabilities include:

  • Self-awareness
  • Self-regulation
  • Empathy
  • Social awareness
  • Relationship management

These skills become particularly important during conflict, uncertainty and organizational change.

Critical Thinking

Modern leaders operate in an environment filled with dashboards, reports, recommendations and AI-generated information.

They need to distinguish between:

  • Facts and assumptions
  • Evidence and opinion
  • Correlation and causation
  • Urgency and importance
  • Useful signals and noise

Decision-Making

Leadership often means making decisions without perfect information.

A useful decision process is:

Problem → Evidence → Options → Trade-offs → Decision → Action → Review

Not every decision needs the same level of analysis.

Reversible decisions can often be made faster than high-impact decisions that are difficult to reverse.

Delegation

Delegation is not simply assigning tasks.

Effective delegation clarifies:

  • The expected outcome
  • Decision boundaries
  • Available resources
  • Timing
  • Escalation conditions
  • Accountability

This gives people autonomy without creating ambiguity.

Coaching

Leaders do not need to provide every answer.

Coaching helps people develop their own problem-solving and decision-making capabilities.

Useful coaching questions include:

  • What outcome are you trying to achieve?
  • What options have you considered?
  • What is preventing progress?
  • What assumptions are you making?
  • What support do you need?

Conflict Management

Healthy teams will sometimes disagree.

The objective is not to eliminate conflict but to prevent disagreement from becoming destructive.

Leaders can help teams focus on:

  • The issue rather than the person
  • Evidence rather than status
  • Shared objectives rather than individual positions
  • Solutions rather than blame

When disagreement becomes persistent or personal, our guide to managing difficult people at work provides practical approaches for communication, boundaries and conflict resolution.

Adaptability

Modern leadership requires the ability to change direction when evidence changes.

Adaptability does not mean changing priorities constantly.

It means maintaining a clear purpose while adjusting the path when circumstances require it.

Modern Leadership Styles

There is no universally superior leadership style.

Effective leaders adapt their approach to the people, task, risk and environment.

Transformational Leadership

Transformational leadership emphasizes vision, motivation and significant change.

It can be useful when organizations need to mobilize people around a new direction.

Servant Leadership

Servant leadership emphasizes supporting people, removing obstacles and helping others succeed.

It can strengthen trust and empowerment when combined with clear accountability.

Situational Leadership

Situational approaches adapt leadership behavior according to context and the needs of the people involved.

A new employee may need more direction than an experienced specialist.

Coaching Leadership

Coaching leaders focus on developing capabilities rather than solving every problem themselves.

Participative Leadership

Participative leadership involves people in decisions where their expertise and perspective can improve the outcome.

Participation does not mean every decision requires consensus.

Directive Leadership

Directive leadership provides clear instructions and tighter control.

It can be appropriate during emergencies, high-risk operations or situations where rapid coordination matters.

How Modern Leaders Build Trust

Trust is difficult to create through slogans.

It develops through repeated behavior.

Leaders can strengthen trust by demonstrating:

  • Consistency
  • Competence
  • Transparency
  • Fairness
  • Reliability
  • Respect
  • Accountability

Trust does not require leaders to share every piece of confidential information.

It requires them to communicate honestly within appropriate boundaries.

Psychological Safety and Modern Leadership

Psychological safety describes an environment where people can raise questions, concerns, mistakes and ideas without unnecessary interpersonal fear.

It matters because leaders rarely have complete visibility into everything happening across an organization.

Employees need to feel able to say:

  • “I think we have a problem.”
  • “I disagree with this assumption.”
  • “I made a mistake.”
  • “I need help.”
  • “I have another idea.”

Psychological safety does not mean lowering standards.

A team can combine high psychological safety with high expectations and strong accountability.

Empowerment vs Micromanagement

Modern leaders need to find a balance between autonomy and control.

Micromanagement can slow decisions and prevent people from developing.

But complete freedom without direction can create confusion.

A better model is:

Clear Outcome + Defined Boundaries + Appropriate Autonomy + Accountability

The leader defines what matters and where constraints exist.

The team determines how to execute within those boundaries whenever appropriate.

Modern Leadership and High-Performing Teams

Leadership shapes the environment in which teams operate.

High-performing teams typically benefit from:

  • Clear goals
  • Complementary skills
  • Trust
  • Useful processes
  • Visible responsibilities
  • Constructive feedback
  • Effective technology
  • Continuous learning

Our Technology and Teamwork guide explores how technology, people, process and leadership combine to create high-performing digital teams.

Leading Cross-Functional Teams

Modern organizations increasingly depend on cross-functional collaboration.

A leader may need to align people from:

  • Technology
  • Operations
  • Finance
  • Cybersecurity
  • Product
  • Marketing
  • Project management
  • Customer-facing functions

Many of these people may not report directly to the leader.

Leadership therefore increasingly depends on influence, shared objectives and clear decision rights.

Create Shared Outcomes

Different functions naturally have different priorities.

A shared outcome helps people understand what they are collectively trying to achieve.

Clarify Decision Rights

Teams need to understand who recommends, who decides, who executes and who needs to be consulted.

Our RACI Matrix guide provides one method for clarifying responsibilities across complex projects.

Modern Leadership in Agile Organizations

Agile environments change the role of leadership.

Instead of controlling every activity, leaders often focus on:

  • Setting direction
  • Clarifying priorities
  • Removing organizational barriers
  • Supporting teams
  • Managing dependencies
  • Creating feedback loops

This does not remove leadership.

It changes where leadership effort is applied.

Our Building Agile Teams guide explores the team practices behind effective Agile collaboration.

Modern Leadership in Hybrid and Remote Work

Hybrid leadership requires intentional communication.

Leaders cannot depend entirely on informal office interactions to understand what is happening.

Distributed teams benefit from:

  • Clear objectives
  • Accessible information
  • Documented decisions
  • Predictable communication
  • Inclusive meetings
  • Asynchronous collaboration
  • Regular human connection

Leaders should also avoid equating physical visibility with productivity.

Performance should be connected to outcomes, quality and contribution rather than simply time spent visibly online or in an office.

Modern Leadership in the AI Era

Artificial intelligence is changing leadership because it changes how information is produced, how work is performed and how some decisions are supported.

AI can assist leaders with activities such as:

  • Research
  • Analysis
  • Summarization
  • Scenario exploration
  • Drafting
  • Knowledge retrieval
  • Workflow automation

But the central leadership challenge is not simply learning how to use an AI tool.

It is determining how humans and AI should work together.

Human leadership and AI assistance model showing human direction, AI support, human judgment and accountability
AI can support leaders with data, analysis and options, while human leaders remain responsible for direction, judgment, ethics and accountability.

For a practical view of how these capabilities are being applied to delivery work, explore our AI in Project Management guide, including planning, risk analysis, reporting and decision support.

What AI Changes for Modern Leaders

As AI becomes more capable, some execution can move from people toward software.

This changes several leadership responsibilities.

Work Design

Leaders need to determine which activities should be:

  • Performed by people
  • Supported by AI
  • Automated
  • Performed through human-AI collaboration

Skills

Teams increasingly need AI literacy alongside domain expertise.

Decision Processes

AI can provide recommendations and analysis, but leaders need to understand where validation and human judgment are required.

Governance

Organizations need rules for appropriate AI use, data access, oversight, monitoring and accountability.

What AI Does Not Replace in Leadership

AI can support many leadership activities, but leadership involves responsibilities that cannot simply be delegated to software.

These include:

  • Setting organizational purpose
  • Taking accountability
  • Building trust
  • Navigating sensitive relationships
  • Making value-based trade-offs
  • Handling complex human situations
  • Leading through uncertainty

The strongest model is therefore not:

Human Leadership vs AI

It is:

Human Leadership + Appropriate AI Assistance

Human Judgment and AI

AI can process large amounts of information and identify patterns quickly.

But decisions exist within context.

Leaders need to consider:

  • Business consequences
  • Human impact
  • Ethics
  • Risk
  • Uncertainty
  • Stakeholder expectations
  • Organizational values

Human judgment therefore becomes particularly important when decisions involve ambiguous trade-offs rather than straightforward optimization.

Modern Leadership and AI Agents

AI agents introduce another leadership challenge.

Some AI systems can perform multi-step tasks, interact with tools and coordinate parts of digital workflows.

This creates a possible operating model:

Human Direction → AI Agent Execution → Monitoring → Human Review → Outcome

Our Agentic AI guide explains how AI agents plan, use tools and perform multi-step work.

Leaders Need to Define Agent Boundaries

Questions include:

  • What actions can the agent perform?
  • What information can it access?
  • What requires approval?
  • Who monitors performance?
  • What happens when the agent fails?
  • Who owns the final outcome?

These are leadership and governance questions, not merely technical configuration questions.

AI Governance Is a Leadership Responsibility

Organizations should not treat AI governance as the responsibility of technical teams alone.

The NIST AI Risk Management Framework emphasizes governance, defined roles, risk management and organizational accountability around AI systems.

Leaders need to establish:

  • Acceptable uses
  • Responsibilities
  • Risk tolerance
  • Human oversight
  • Monitoring
  • Escalation mechanisms
  • Accountability

Leadership becomes even more important as AI systems move from generating information toward performing actions.

Modern Leadership and Digital Transformation

Digital transformation is often described as a technology initiative.

In reality, transformation affects:

  • Processes
  • Skills
  • Roles
  • Customer experiences
  • Decision-making
  • Organizational structures
  • Culture

Leaders therefore need to connect technology investment with organizational change.

Buying technology without redesigning work can limit its value.

Leading Organizational Change

People often resist change when they do not understand it, do not trust it or believe they will lose something important.

Modern leaders should explain:

  • Why change is necessary
  • What will change
  • What will remain stable
  • How people will be affected
  • What support is available
  • How success will be measured

Communication should continue throughout the transformation rather than occur only at launch.

Modern Leadership and Workforce Transformation

AI, automation and changing business models can alter the skills organizations need.

Leaders therefore need to consider technology strategy and workforce strategy together.

This includes:

  • Reskilling
  • Upskilling
  • Role redesign
  • Talent mobility
  • Leadership development
  • AI literacy

Our Workforce Transformation guide explores how organizations can align skills, AI and workforce strategy.

Leading Through Uncertainty

Leaders rarely have complete information during periods of significant change.

The challenge is to provide enough clarity for action without pretending uncertainty does not exist.

A useful approach is to separate:

  • What we know
  • What we believe
  • What we do not yet know
  • What we are doing next

This can build credibility because people can distinguish evidence from assumptions.

Crisis Leadership

During a crisis, leadership often becomes more directive.

Priorities include:

  • Protecting people
  • Understanding the situation
  • Establishing clear decision authority
  • Communicating frequently
  • Coordinating actions
  • Managing immediate risk

As the situation stabilizes, leaders can gradually return more decision-making autonomy to teams.

Ethical Modern Leadership

Leadership decisions affect employees, customers, partners and communities.

Ethical leadership requires more than legal compliance.

Leaders should consider:

  • Who benefits?
  • Who could be harmed?
  • Is the decision fair?
  • Can the decision be explained?
  • Are incentives creating undesirable behavior?
  • Would we be comfortable defending the decision publicly?

This becomes particularly important when technology enables decisions to scale quickly.

Inclusive Leadership

Inclusive leadership aims to ensure relevant perspectives can contribute to decisions and work.

Practical behaviors include:

  • Inviting different perspectives
  • Listening without immediate dismissal
  • Making meeting participation accessible
  • Using transparent criteria for opportunities
  • Recognizing different working styles
  • Challenging unnecessary barriers

Inclusion does not require leaders to accept every idea.

It requires people to have a meaningful opportunity to contribute.

Modern Leadership and Employee Wellbeing

Sustainable performance matters.

Leaders influence workload, priorities, meeting culture, expectations and how teams respond to pressure.

Warning signs of an unhealthy operating model can include:

  • Constant urgency
  • Unmanageable workloads
  • Excessive meetings
  • Unclear priorities
  • Persistent after-hours expectations
  • Low recovery time

Our Employee Wellbeing and Mental Health at Work guide explores how organizations can approach wellbeing more systematically.

Developing Future Leaders

Leadership development should not begin only after someone receives a management title.

Organizations can build leadership capabilities through:

  • Stretch assignments
  • Mentoring
  • Coaching
  • Cross-functional projects
  • Decision-making opportunities
  • Feedback
  • Leadership education
  • Reflection

Future leaders need opportunities to practice judgment and accountability rather than only study leadership concepts.

How to Improve Your Modern Leadership Skills

Step 1: Understand Yourself

Identify your strengths, weaknesses, assumptions and leadership habits.

Step 2: Ask for Feedback

Compare how you intend to lead with how others actually experience your leadership.

Step 3: Choose One Development Priority

Avoid trying to improve ten leadership capabilities simultaneously.

Choose one meaningful behavior and practice it deliberately.

Step 4: Practice in Real Situations

Leadership develops through application.

Use meetings, decisions, projects and difficult conversations as opportunities to practice.

Step 5: Reflect

After important situations, ask:

  • What happened?
  • What worked?
  • What did I miss?
  • What would I do differently?

Step 6: Learn Continuously

Leadership requirements change as organizations, technology and teams evolve.

A Practical Modern Leadership Development Plan

Modern leadership development roadmap showing a six-month progression from assessment to growth and leadership impact
A practical six-month roadmap to assess leadership strengths, build foundations, practice new skills, lead initiatives, measure progress and expand impact.
Period Focus Example Action
Weeks 1–2 Self-awareness Gather feedback and identify one development priority
Weeks 3–4 Communication Practice clearer objectives and decision explanations
Month 2 Delegation Delegate outcomes with explicit decision boundaries
Month 3 Coaching Use questions before giving solutions
Month 4 Strategic thinking Connect team priorities with wider business outcomes
Month 5 AI leadership Identify appropriate human-AI workflows and governance
Month 6 Review Gather new feedback and assess progress

How to Measure Leadership Effectiveness

Leadership cannot be measured accurately through a single metric.

A balanced view can consider:

Leaders can connect strategic objectives with measurable outcomes using frameworks such as KPIs and OKRs.

Dimension Possible Indicator
Direction Understanding of priorities
Execution Delivery against meaningful outcomes
Decision-making Decision quality and speed
People Capability development and sustainable performance
Teamwork Collaboration and dependency management
Adaptability Ability to respond to change
Trust Quality of feedback and escalation
Innovation Useful experimentation and learning

Metrics should be interpreted in context rather than used as simplistic leadership scores.

Common Modern Leadership Mistakes

Micromanaging

Controlling every detail prevents people from developing autonomy.

Delegating Without Context

Autonomy works best when people understand the objective and boundaries.

Avoiding Difficult Decisions

Delaying an uncomfortable decision can create larger problems.

Communicating Only When Everything Is Certain

During change, silence can create more uncertainty than acknowledging what is not yet known.

Confusing Consensus With Collaboration

People can contribute to a decision without everyone having veto power.

Using Technology to Solve Human Problems

Another platform will not automatically repair poor trust, unclear priorities or weak leadership.

Following AI Without Sufficient Judgment

AI-generated recommendations can be useful inputs, but leaders remain responsible for understanding the context and appropriate level of validation.

Ignoring Wellbeing

Short periods of intense effort may sometimes be necessary, but permanent overload is not a sustainable operating model.

The Future of Modern Leadership

The future of leadership is unlikely to be defined by technology replacing leaders.

It is more likely to involve technology changing what leaders spend their time doing.

As AI performs more analysis, drafting and workflow execution, leaders may spend relatively more attention on:

  • Direction
  • Judgment
  • Prioritization
  • Relationships
  • Trust
  • Work design
  • Governance
  • Capability building

The World Economic Forum has highlighted this shift toward human-centered leadership capabilities as AI changes how work is performed.

At the same time, leaders will need enough AI fluency to understand what the technology can and cannot do.

The future leader is therefore neither purely human-centered nor purely technology-centered.

Modern leadership connects human capability with technological capability while maintaining clear human accountability.

Frequently Asked Questions About Modern Leadership

What Is Modern Leadership?

Modern leadership is the ability to create direction, enable people, make effective decisions and adapt to changing conditions while remaining accountable for outcomes.

What Are the Most Important Modern Leadership Skills?

Important skills include strategic thinking, communication, active listening, emotional intelligence, critical thinking, decision-making, delegation, coaching, conflict management and adaptability.

What Is the Difference Between Leadership and Management?

Management generally emphasizes organization, coordination and execution, while leadership places greater emphasis on direction, alignment, judgment and change. Effective professionals often need capabilities from both.

What Is the Best Leadership Style?

There is no universally best style. Effective leaders adapt their approach according to the people, task, risk and situation.

What Is Transformational Leadership?

Transformational leadership focuses on creating a compelling direction and motivating people around meaningful organizational change.

What Is Servant Leadership?

Servant leadership emphasizes supporting people, removing obstacles and helping others perform and develop.

Why Is Psychological Safety Important for Leaders?

Psychological safety makes it easier for people to raise concerns, ask questions, share ideas and discuss mistakes, giving leaders better access to information about what is really happening.

How Is AI Changing Leadership?

AI can support analysis, information retrieval, drafting, automation and other activities. This increases the importance of work design, AI literacy, governance, judgment and clearly defined accountability.

Can AI Replace Leaders?

AI can assist with many leadership-related tasks, but leadership also involves accountability, trust, relationships, values, judgment and difficult trade-offs that remain organizational and human responsibilities.

What Is Leadership in the AI Era?

Leadership in the AI era involves combining human judgment and accountability with appropriate AI capabilities while defining clear boundaries for automation and human oversight.

How Can I Become a Better Leader?

Develop self-awareness, seek feedback, practice communication and delegation, improve decision-making, coach others, reflect on real experiences and continuously develop your skills.

How Do Leaders Build Trust?

Trust develops through consistent behavior, competence, honesty, fairness, reliability, respect and accountability.

How Should Leaders Manage Hybrid Teams?

Hybrid leaders should emphasize clear outcomes, accessible information, documented decisions, inclusive communication, asynchronous collaboration and intentional relationship building.

Conclusion: Modern Leadership Is Human and Digital

Modern leadership is not defined by a job title, a personality type or a single leadership style.

It is the ability to create the conditions in which people can understand the direction, make good decisions, collaborate effectively and adapt to change.

A practical model is:

Modern Leadership = Direction + People + Decisions + Adaptability + Technology + Accountability

Technology is becoming an increasingly important part of that equation.

Artificial intelligence can help leaders analyze information, explore options and automate parts of work. AI agents may eventually coordinate increasingly complex workflows.

But increased technological capability makes leadership accountability more important, not less.

Organizations still need people who can decide what matters, understand context, navigate trade-offs, build trust and take responsibility for outcomes.

The strongest modern leaders will therefore not compete with technology.

They will understand how to combine human capability with technology while preserving the judgment, relationships and accountability that effective leadership requires.

Modern leaders also need the ability to create fair workplaces and make commercially sound decisions. Continue with our guides to DEI in the workplace and finance for non-finance managers.

Get Practical Insights from TechTeamSynergy

Join TechTeamSynergy Weekly for practical insights, frameworks, templates and resources covering Technology, Team and Transformation.

Join TechTeamSynergy Weekly →

Comments are closed.